EXPLORE

Restorative Justice: Principles and Practices

Restorative justice asks who was harmed, what they need, and whose obligation it is to repair the harm. This guide explains the approach, where it is used, and where it should not be.

Definition

Understanding Restorative Justice

Restorative justice is an approach to wrongdoing that views harm as a violation of people and relationships, and that seeks, where safe and voluntary, to involve those affected in identifying and meeting the needs and obligations that result.

Conventional criminal justice often asks three questions: What law was broken? Who did it? What punishment do they deserve? Howard Zehr, whose book Changing Lenses (1990) is a foundational text in the field, proposed a different set of guiding questions:

  • Who has been hurt?
  • What are their needs?
  • Whose obligations are these?
  • What are the causes?
  • Who has a stake in the situation?
  • What is the appropriate process to involve stakeholders in putting things right?

Restorative justice is not a single program. It is a set of principles that can inform many practices, from victim-offender dialogue in criminal cases to restorative conversations in a school.

History

Historical and Contemporary Context

Many restorative ideas are old. Practices focused on repairing harm and restoring community relationships exist in numerous cultural and religious traditions, including those of many Indigenous peoples. The modern restorative justice movement grew from several sources.

  • Victim-offender reconciliation

    An experiment in Kitchener, Ontario, in 1974, in which two young men who had vandalized property met the people they had harmed, is often cited as an early modern example. It helped inspire victim-offender reconciliation programs in North America.

  • Family group conferencing

    New Zealand's Children, Young Persons, and Their Families Act of 1989 made family group conferences central to youth justice, influenced in part by Māori approaches to resolving wrongdoing within extended families and communities.

  • Theory and research

    The criminologist John Braithwaite's Crime, Shame and Reintegration (1989) distinguished stigmatizing shame from "reintegrative shaming," which condemns the act while respecting the person. Zehr's writing shaped the movement's vocabulary.

  • International recognition

    In 2002 the United Nations Economic and Social Council adopted basic principles on the use of restorative justice programs in criminal matters, emphasizing voluntary participation and procedural safeguards.

Today, restorative practices are used in some criminal justice systems, juvenile justice programs, schools, universities, workplaces and community organizations, with wide variation in how they are designed.

Principle

Accountability and Repairing Harm

In restorative justice, accountability means more than accepting punishment. It means understanding the impact of one's actions, taking responsibility for them and taking active steps to repair harm as far as possible.

Repair can take many forms: a sincere apology, returning or replacing property, paying restitution, community service, changing behavior, or participating in education or treatment. What counts as meaningful repair should be shaped by the needs of the people harmed.

Three pillars

Zehr summarized restorative justice in three pillars:

  1. Harms and needs. Focus first on the harm done and the needs it created.
  2. Obligations. Wrongs create obligations, especially for those responsible.
  3. Engagement. Those affected should have the opportunity to participate.
Practice

Restorative Dialogue

Restorative processes typically involve structured, facilitated conversation. Common formats include:

Victim-offender dialogue

A facilitated meeting between a person harmed and the person responsible, usually after careful preparation of both. In serious cases, preparation may take months.

Conferences

Meetings that include supporters of both parties, such as family members, alongside a trained facilitator, to discuss the harm and agree on a plan.

Circles

Group discussions in which participants speak in turn, often using a talking piece, to share perspectives, build relationships or respond to harm.

Restorative dialogue can also be indirect. When a face-to-face meeting is not appropriate or wanted, facilitators may pass messages or letters between parties, a process sometimes called shuttle dialogue.

Stakeholders

Community Participation

Restorative justice treats wrongdoing as something that affects not only individuals but also communities. Community members may participate as supporters, as people indirectly affected, or as volunteers who help monitor agreements.

Community involvement can strengthen social support for both those harmed and those responsible. It also raises questions: Who defines "the community"? Are all relevant voices included? Could community pressure become unfair to one party? Thoughtful programs address these questions explicitly.

Priority

Victim-Centered Considerations

Restorative justice is meant to give people who have been harmed a greater voice than they often have in conventional processes. That goal is only met if programs place victims' safety, needs and choices at the center.

  • Victims should never be pressured to meet, forgive or reconcile.
  • Preparation should help them decide what they want from the process.
  • They should be able to bring a support person and to stop at any time.
  • Access to counseling, advocacy and legal information should remain available.
Safeguard

Voluntariness is a core principle. Participants should give informed consent, understand what the process involves and what its consequences might be, and be free to withdraw.

For the person responsible for harm, participation usually requires acknowledging the basic facts of what happened. A restorative process is not a forum for determining guilt when facts are disputed. In criminal contexts, participants' legal rights, including the right to legal advice, should be protected.

When participation is offered as an alternative to a formal sanction, there is a risk that consent is not truly free. Programs need to take this into account.

Schools

Restorative Practices in Education

Many schools have adopted restorative practices as an alternative or complement to exclusionary discipline such as suspension. Practices include community-building circles, restorative questions after an incident, and formal conferences for more serious harm.

Proponents argue that these approaches strengthen relationships and keep students connected to school. Critics and some educators caution that, without adequate training, staffing and clear expectations, restorative programs can leave teachers unsupported or fail to address serious behavior.

The research picture is mixed. For example, a randomized study in Pittsburgh public schools published by the RAND Corporation in 2018 reported reductions in suspensions, but did not find academic improvements and noted some negative academic results for middle school students. Results depend heavily on implementation.

Common restorative questions

  • What happened?
  • What were you thinking at the time?
  • Who has been affected by what happened, and how?
  • What do you think you need to do to make things right?
  • For the person harmed: What has been the hardest thing for you? What do you need?
Ethics

Limitations and Ethical Concerns

Restorative approaches do not replace legal protections, child safeguarding procedures, emergency services or professional support. They are one option among several, and they are not suitable in every case.

  • Safety and power. In situations involving domestic violence, sexual violence, ongoing intimidation or significant power imbalances, face-to-face processes can endanger or retraumatize victims. Many programs exclude these cases or use specialized protocols.
  • Pressure to forgive. Forgiveness and reconciliation may happen, but they must never be expectations or conditions.
  • Net-widening. Programs intended as alternatives can sometimes draw people into formal oversight for minor matters that would otherwise have been dropped.
  • Inconsistency. Outcomes that depend on participants' agreement can vary between similar cases, raising questions of equal treatment.
  • Cultural appropriation. Programs that draw on Indigenous traditions should involve those communities and respect their knowledge rather than borrowing practices without context.
Evidence

Evaluating Restorative Outcomes

Researchers evaluate restorative justice using several outcomes: victim satisfaction and well-being, perceived fairness, completion of agreements, effects on reoffending and costs.

Reviews of research on face-to-face restorative conferencing, including work by Lawrence Sherman and Heather Strang, have generally found high levels of victim satisfaction and some reductions in repeat offending, with effects varying by type of offense and program. Not all studies show benefits, and study quality varies.

When evaluating a specific program, useful questions include: What was the comparison group? Were participants randomly assigned or self-selected? What outcomes were measured, and for how long? Were the voices of those harmed included in the evaluation? Tips for reading such studies appear on the Learning Resources page.

FAQ

Common Questions

Is restorative justice a "soft" option?

Participants often describe it as demanding. Facing the people you harmed and hearing directly about the impact can be harder than a conventional hearing. That said, it is not designed as punishment, and whether it is appropriate depends on the case.

Does restorative justice replace the courts?

Generally not. In most places it operates alongside or within formal systems, for example as a diversion option, as part of sentencing or after a sentence. It does not remove legal rights or protections.

Does the person harmed have to forgive?

No. Forgiveness is a personal choice and should never be required or expected.

Can restorative practices be used for serious harm?

Some programs offer victim-initiated dialogue in serious cases, sometimes years after an offense, with extensive preparation by specialized facilitators. These processes are always voluntary and are not appropriate for everyone.

How is this connected to broader questions of justice?

Restorative justice is one of several ideas about how societies should respond to wrongdoing. The Peace and Justice page compares it with retributive and other concepts of justice.

Continue to Peace and Justice

Place restorative approaches within a wider discussion of justice, equity and peaceful social change.

Explore Peace and Justice